01 March

Sticky

Google Wins Mandamus at Federal Circuit in EDTX Venue Dispute

Posted by COFFYLAW, LLC

in Blog

The Federal Circuit recently granted a petition for a writ of mandamus to Google LLC (“Google”) finding that venue was improper for a case filed by Super Interconnected Technologies LLC (“SIT”) against Google in the Eastern District of Texas. See In re Google LLC, No. 2019-126, 2020 U.S. App. LEXIS 4588 (Fed. Cir. Feb. 13, 2020) (Before Dyk, Wallach, and Taranto, Circuit Judges) (Order for the Court, Dyk, Circuit Judge) (Concurring opinion, Wallach, Circuit Judge). SIT brought suit against Google in the Eastern District of Texas arguing that venue was proper under the patent venue statute (28 U.S.C. § 1400(b)). SIT filed its suit after the...

29 February

0 Comments

Sticky

CAFC Orders Settlement Agreement Enforced, Tosses Summary Judgment of Non-Infringement

Posted by COFFYLAW, LLC

in Blog

Even though a settlement agreement may call for future performance, it generally renders the underlying action moot. The Federal Circuit may enforce a settlement agreement that resolves patent infringement claims as long as the proceedings are still ongoing. The Federal Circuit recently issued an opinion vacating the district court’s grant of summary judgment motions of non-infringement and remanding with instructions to enforce a settlement agreement between Serta Simmons Bedding, LLC and Dreamwell, Ltd. (collectively, “Serta Simmons”) and Casper Sleep Inc. (“Casper”). See Serta Simmons Bedding, LLC v. Casper Sleep Inc., No. 19-1098, 2020 U.S. App. LEXIS 4467 (Fed Cir. Feb. 13, 2020) (Before...

29 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Ranking the Top ITC Firms and Attorneys

Posted by COFFYLAW, LLC

in Blog

With the International Trade Commission (ITC) having become an increasingly important option for patent owners since eBay v. MercExchange made it harder to obtain injunctions in the United States, more firms are becoming ITC specialists. The ITC is a unique and fast-paced venue, so choosing experienced counsel is crucial. Last month, we released our first ITC Intelligence Report. For the first time, we ranked ITC law firms and attorneys based on their performance and activity. Our research team analyzed the outcome of 308 ITC Section 337 Investigations, filed from January 1, 2014, through December 1, 2019. For all the terminated cases, we identified the outcome (e.g.,...

28 February

0 Comments

Sticky

With Congress Focused on Copyright, Industry Must Deliver Solutions to the Piracy Problem

Posted by COFFYLAW, LLC

in Blog

“With respect to digital piracy, the question is whether and to what extent the industry will be able to respond in a cooperative and comprehensive manner to any level that will make a difference, and whether it is already too late.” A recently released report from the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation (ITIF) argues that while there is no easy solution to the ongoing scourge of digital content piracy on the Internet, voluntary agreements between copyright holders and payment processors, advertising networks, domain name registrars, search engines, and other stakeholders can serve as an important complement to legislative and other efforts by governments. “Experience...

20 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Oracle Files Opening Brief at U.S. Supreme Court in Copyright Fight with Google

Posted by COFFYLAW, LLC

in Blog

In the latest stage of the Supreme Court battle between Oracle America, Inc. (Oracle) and Google, Oracle filed its opening brief with the Court on February 12. Google’s petition for a writ of certiorari was granted in November 2019 and asks the Court to consider: “1. Whether copyright protection extends to a software interface” and “2. Whether, as the jury found, petitioner’s use of a software interface in the context of creating a new computer program constitutes fair use.” The Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) previously unanimously reversed a district court decision that held Oracle’s code as uncopyrightable, finding it well-established that...

19 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Bayh-Dole 40: Celebrating the Past, Protecting the Future

Posted by COFFYLAW, LLC

in Blog

“When Bayh-Dole is mentioned in the current political debate it’s misrepresented by alleging that it empowers the bureaucracy to take technologies away from their developers if their price isn’t “reasonable.” Of course, the law says no such thing.” It’s highly appropriate that the 40th anniversary of the Bayh-Dole Act occurs in a year as politically contentious as that in which it passed. In 1980, many predicted that our best years were behind us and that the United States would soon lose its place as the world’s economic superpower. Experts proclaimed the best remedy was to adopt the “Japan, Inc.” model, where...

18 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Time to Close the Gap: Is the PTAB Looking at Prosecution Histories in IPRs?

Posted by COFFYLAW, LLC

in Blog

“The gap between the scope of review required under Phillips and that implemented by the Board plainly does the public a disservice. The public has a right to rely on the prosecution history in order to understand the scope of a patent’s issued claims.” If a recent decision denying institution of an inter partes review (IPR) is any indicator, the answer to the question above seems to be no, the Board does not routinely review a challenged patent’s prosecution history—even when the history includes a prior Board decision construing claim terms at issue in the IPR. In Apple Inc. v. Uniloc 2017 LLC, IPR2019-00753,...

18 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Earth to Google: Here’s Why APIs Need to be Copyrightable

Posted by COFFYLAW, LLC

in Blog

On January 6, 2020, Google submitted its brief in Google v. Oracle, kicking off the Supreme Court case that many are calling the “copyright case of the decade.” The suit pits the search engine platform controlling 93% of the worldwide search market against Oracle, the owner of the ubiquitous Java program, which submitted its response brief last week. After attempting and failing to secure the rights to Java, Google decided to cease negotiating and instead replicated 37 API packages from the copyrighted program, a decision that precipitated the years-long lawsuit. Making Google Hum An API, or application programming interface, is what allows different parts of a computer program...

18 February

0 Comments

Sticky

This Week in Washington IP: Balancing Interests in Tech Exports, Predictive Analytics in Criminal Justice and Energy Storage Innovation

Posted by COFFYLAW, LLC

in Blog

his week in Washington IP events, it’s quiet on Capitol Hill as both the House of Representatives and the Senate enter work periods for the week following Monday’s Presidents’ Day holiday. However, the Center for Strategic & International Studies is hosting a series of events focused on situational awareness technologies for nuclear arms, the recent Privacy Framework from NIST and advances in energy storage technologies across the automotive and electrical grid industries. Elsewhere in DC, the Brookings Institution will explore issues involving the use of predictive AI analytics in the criminal justice system, and the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation...

17 February

0 Comments

Sticky

Six Years After Alice: 61.8% of U.S. Patents Issued in 2019 Were ‘Software-Related’—up 21.6% from 2018

Posted by COFFYLAW, LLC

in Blog

As an update to my posts from 2017 and 2019, it has now been more than six years since the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2014 Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank decision. Still, the IP bar awaits a clear and reliable test to determine when exactly a software (or computer-implemented) claim is patentable versus being simply an abstract idea “free to all men and reserved exclusively to none.” The USPTO’s Section 101 guidelines interpreting Alice—and the accompanying 46 examples—have not cleared the confusion, and Alice continues to distract the USPTO, courts, and practitioners from focusing properly on Sections 102 (novelty) and 103 (obviousness). The net effects still being increased cost, lower patent quality,...

Areas We Serve

Google Wins Mandamus at Federal Circuit in EDTX Venue Dispute

CAFC Orders Settlement Agreement Enforced, Tosses Summary Judgment of Non-Infringement

Ranking the Top ITC Firms and Attorneys

With Congress Focused on Copyright, Industry Must Deliver Solutions to the Piracy Problem

Oracle Files Opening Brief at U.S. Supreme Court in Copyright Fight with Google

Bayh-Dole 40: Celebrating the Past, Protecting the Future

Time to Close the Gap: Is the PTAB Looking at Prosecution Histories in IPRs?

Earth to Google: Here’s Why APIs Need to be Copyrightable

This Week in Washington IP: Balancing Interests in Tech Exports, Predictive Analytics in Criminal Justice and Energy Storage Innovation

Six Years After Alice: 61.8% of U.S. Patents Issued in 2019 Were ‘Software-Related’—up 21.6% from 2018

Areas We Serve

Maplewood Location

Brooklyn Location

Clifton Location